Well despite everything I said (off line) about the problems with the iPhone I got one. two things lead to this happening:
- my mate Steve lent me his iPod touch (upgraded to v2.0 software)
- my old phone had become unreliable... hardware glitches
Playing with the iPod Touch was amazing, I loved the web browser, the apps were very cool and (most importantly) I discovered that I liked the keyboard. Honestly that last one really surprised me. I'd thought it was the tactile feedback over the flat touch screen that was the thing I liked... actually it was just that on the windows mobile devices I needed to use a stylus and that (for me) is the deal breaker.
Anyhow... as I said my phone (Dopod c730) had become unreliable, I'd reflashed the firmware and so on but it still was flaky so I figured it was a hardware problem and switched back to my iMate k-jam (brick of a thing). My contract with Optus was up so I decided to get a new phone. Here were the features I wanted:
- Make calls
- messaging: text and email (plus the occasional picture message)
- Synchronise with Outlook
- web browsing
- music
- GPS
- File viewing
- other random apps as I feel like it (some games)
I decided to have a look at everything: Nokia, Sony Ericson, Windows Mobile and the iPhone. I went into the store thinking I'd get a GPS equipped Nokia or the Samsung i780. In the end I made an impulse decision to get the iPhone. Why? Well apparently the GPS on the nokia sucked and it was going to take ages to get the Samsung and the iPhone was there (plus it was cool and shiny) also it was cheaper! 500MB of data and you can only get that on an iPhone plan
OK... So... I've had it for about a week now and what are my thoughts? (BTW I did do my research and knew of most of the limitations)
Not having copy and paste haven't really bothered me, but I thought it would.
The lack of MMS, recording video and attaching anything to an existing email are a theoretical pain: they haven't really bothered me yet, but it annoys me that you can't do then (yes I do know you can email a picture to someone, but if I was replying to an email and wanted to attach a pic... no luck, also attach more than one picture to an email, no can do)
A "synchronise this folder to my phone" with a filter on the file types (ie nothing with DRM potential, if they must) is a glaring omission, particularly as it has viewers for all the office document types and PDF and so on... also no upload to the web. BTW the "Files" app $10 in the app store gets around this to a degree but it's a bit fiddly to set up. Although at work today I had files I wanted to put on my phone and the only way I could do it was to ftp them to a server from my PC and download them to my phone using a terminal emulator and command line ftp!!! All this because I can't put the phone onto the work network and I can't save attachments.
PIM limitations: No way to send contacts via bluetooth or sms or email. No way to send anything except one picture. Can't send appointments or see who else was invited to an appointment either. can create an appointment, but not invite a contact.
Actually the thing I miss the most is stereo bluetooth. I knew it wouldn't be there. I like to listen to music while I cycle and have a Motorola S9. It was great, pause/play, next/previous track, volume control, all with my phone safely in my backpack... take calls too... even a wired remote with those 5 controls (plus one for answer call) would probably do.
It seems that most of the 3rd party accessories don't work. I spent hours walking around town trying stereo bluetooth ipod adapters, but no go. I also took back an iTrip for hte radio thing as it was pretty unreliable and couldn't charge the phone.
I'm still just getting used to the iPod functions. Actually this makes me feel really stupid. I keep bumping into stuff that doesn't work the way I expect it to. The hardest was making a play list on the fly... I've got it working now, but it took me ages. Also itunes just rubs me up the wrong way... hard to explain, but it just does.
I just haven't gotten used to iTunes. It really
really irritates me. I can't quite put my finger on it, so I'm putting that down to lack of familiarity. Also why can't I sync with 2 PCs? All my music is from ripped CDs. I have work and home PCs with music and podcasts I'd like to copy but I get "You can only sync an iPhone with one iTunes library..." all the iTunes are authorised with the one account (as is my phone) so what gives?
Oh and the battery life (compared to my old phone) is fine, I can last a day if I turn wi-fi off and I sync during the day at work so I'm OK with it.
In spite of the negatives; the UI is gorgeous and must have good support for the apps as they are generally consistent and look nice. The browser is fantastic (I can live without flash) I'm also keen to give some development a go, but for that I'd need a mac and try as I might I can't get a stable Mac VM or install OSX on one of my laptops. So that won't be happening any time soon ...
All up part of me says "just go back to Windows Mobile" but I'd miss the browser and keyboard (no, seriously I would)
I really miss the openness of the Microsoft world. So many things on the iPhone/iTunes seem designed for revenue and making you work the way they want you to. Rather then the way you want to; or have I just gotten used to the Microsoft way of doing things? Why is apple so closed about the "why" of somethings eg:
- Why no mms
- Why no Stereo Bluetooth!!
- Why no attaching thigns to emails
- Why no file browsing? (I could store files on my old suffle why not here?)
- Why limit the PIM? This is a great PDA!